Our Story
The corner of 92 Maple Street has been serving Florence, MA since the days of jukeboxes and after-school hangouts.
It all started as Andy’s Pizza in the 1960s, later becoming the Irish Pizza House, and eventually landing in the hands of John and Anne Kostides, who renamed it A-1 Pizza. Smartly chosen to be the first in the phone book*, “A-1” soon became the first stop for hungry locals looking for a hot slice or a classic grinder.
A Neighborhood Staple Since the 1960s
A-1 Pizza’s Legacy
For decades, A-1 was the go-to pizzeria in Florence — a place where teens grabbed a slice after school, couples had first dates over a shared grinder, and families picked up pizza on Friday nights after a baseball game or in advance of family movie night. Its menu was classic and comforting, its atmosphere casual and welcoming. It wasn’t just a restaurant; it was part of the rhythm of daily life in the Pioneer Valley.
A New Chapter Begins
When the opportunity arose to take over this much-loved spot, Georgianna Brunton knew it was meant to be. Already the proud owner of Miss Florence Diner (a National Register of Historic Places landmark in just down the street) Georgianna had a vision: honor the history of A-1 Pizza while giving the space a fresh identity that matched today’s Florence. And so, Miss Flo’s Pizzeria was born! Full of sass, sauce (marinara of course) and a welcoming, yet casual atmosphere, just like the good ol’ days.
* Hey Kids…or anyone too young (or too old) to remember…a “phone book” is like a big book of phone numbers, similar to a contact list on a phone, but much older, heavier and generally more cumbersome to use. In olden times, people used these massive books to find things they needed (like an awesome local pizza shop that serves hot and delicious pizza exactly the way you like it). Using a phone book was kinda like doing an internet search, but slower and a lot more work.
“Great food. Had a meatball grinder. Very filling and reasonable price. I'll definitely be back!”
- David (Local Grinder Connoisseur)
Our Vision
At Miss Flo’s Pizzeria, our mission is to honor Florence’s history while feeding its future. We provide consistently delicious, approachable food in a welcoming space that celebrates community, connection, and local legacy. By blending nostalgia with fresh flavor, we strive to be more than a restaurant — we’re a neighborhood hangout where memories are made, shared, and savored.
Do drop in, we’d love to have you.
“Absolutely unbeatable ambiance and generous slices!”
- A. Wheeler-Davis (Who Clearly has Exceptional Taste)
Georgianna Brunton is no stranger to running beloved local institutions. In 2018, she became the steward of the Miss Florence Diner, a historic Worcester Lunch Car Company diner built in 1941 and listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Under her leadership, the diner has thrived, blending timeless charm with modern hospitality enticing countless patrons to step back in time and enjoy a traditional diner meal with all the fixens.
Beyond her diner businesses, Georgianna is deeply involved and serves as a community leader in Florence, Massachusetts. She serves as President of the Florence Civic & Business Association, is a board member of the Northampton Family Fourth Committee, and participates actively in the Northampton Chamber of Commerce. Her dedication to service isn’t just professional — it’s personal. Georgie believes in the power of local businesses to knit communities together, to provide safe, welcoming spaces where everyone feels they belong.
In 2025, Georgianna acquired a second longstanding restaurant also in Florence, A-1 Pizza. This beloved pizzeria has been in operation since the early 1960’s, enjoyed by countless locals over the years. Now under the new ownership, once again, Georgianna strives to steward this long-standing business into the next chapter with exceptional care. Her hope is to honor the legacy of the pizza shop while also breathing new life into this historic space.
“Food isn’t just about filling plates — it’s about creating places where people can connect, laugh, and feel at home. I like my food hot, my humor a little sassy, and my community strong.”
Meet Georgianna Brunton
We’re proud to carry on the tradition of feeding Florence since the 1960s — now as Miss Flo’s Pizzeria. Our mission is to be the neighborhood pizza shop you can always count on, for comfort, for connection, and for a little slice of Florence history. Stop by, say hello, and taste a slice of local history reimagined.
We’ve updated the menu to bring you an even wider range of grinders, pizzas, and fresh salads — plus creamy, flavorful gelato in crowd-favorite flavors like Salted Caramel, Pistachio, and Amarena Cherry. You’ll still find the classics you’ve always loved, made fresh and to order with the kind of friendly service that will keep you coming back.
Located in the heart of Florence Village, just minutes from Northampton, Easthampton, and Leeds, Miss Flo’s Pizzeria is the perfect spot whether you’re stopping in for lunch, grabbing takeout for a movie night, or picking up a late dinner after the game. No matter when you visit, you’ll always be greeted with hot food and a warm smile. Unless you ordered salad….in which case you’ll certainly receive cold food, but still a warm smile!
Miss Flo’s Pizzeria proudly carries forward the legacy of A-1 Pizza while infusing it with new energy and heart. It’s a place where:
History meets today: honoring the building’s decades-long role as a gathering spot while refreshing it with a modern menu and atmosphere. During renovations, we were delighted to discover original tin ceilings in our historic space. Come check it out!
Community comes first: a safe, welcoming hangout for all ages, from teens grabbing a slice after school to families celebrating milestones. Let our pizzeria be your local haunt, whether it’s to celebrate a big win or a random Tuesday night, we invite you to enjoy something truly tasty!
Good food fuels good memories: with hand-tossed pizzas, hearty grinders, crisp salads, creamy gelato and desserts, we know what hits the spot. Drop by to dine in or order takeout and taste all the goodness Miss Flo’s Pizzeria has to offer!
